topbar
Login
User Name
Password
     
Information Bulletins
 
Who is onBalance?
Que Hales
Douge Latta
Kim Skinner
 
What has onBalance accomplished?
Accomplishments
     
Email update series
Soft Spots
Soft Spots Study
the soft spot e-mail update series
the Dow Whitney Report and the Chapman Study
Dow Whitney
critique
Additional reading
Surface Discoloration
           
Swimming Pool Water Treatment

Effects on White Cement Surfaces

Dr. Dwain R. Chapman

March 10, 1971
A Study of Marcite (Plaster)
Deterioration in Swimming Pools
Dr. E. Dow Whitney
November 1, 1990
Page 1 / Introduction / 1st sentence:

Water is near to being a universal solvent. Even in its present state it can cause the dissolution of all but the most stable of materials.

Page 28 / Section 5.1 / 1st sentence:

Water is near to being a universal solvent and it can cause the dissolution of all but the most stable of materials.

Page 1 / Introduction / last sentance of 1st paragraph and entire following paragraph:

The water and whatever else is present in the water will almost always have some effect on the container.

The composition of the container will be the determining factor in the nature and extent of the effects. To determine the effects of swimming pool water, and the chemicals used in the water, on white cement it is of importance that we know the composition and properties of the various substituents which are present in the cement.

Page 29 / Section 5.1 / last sentance of 1st paragraph and entire following paragraph:

Water and whatever else is present in the water will almost always have some effect on its container.

The composition of the container, in this case the marcite shell of the swimming pool, will be the determining factor in the nature and extent of these effects. To determine the effects of swimming pool water and the chemicals used in the water on white cement it is of importance to know the composition and properties of the various substituents which are present in portland cement.

Pages 1-3 / Introduction / 3rd paragraph of Introduction through end of introduction except for final paragraph:

The primary raw material for the manufacture of Portland cement is calcium carbonate or limestone. The limestone is mixed with clay containing silica, aluminum and ferric oxides in the proper proportions and then burned in a rotary kiln at a temperature of about 1450ºC (2640ºF). A hard "clinker" is formed which is cooled and then ground in a mill. During the grinding about three percent of gypsum is added to help control the setting time of the finished cement.

The primary compounds entering into the composition of finished Portland cemet are: Tricalcium silicate, 3 CaO•SiO2 (54%); Dicalcium silicate, 2 CaO•SiO2 (17%); Tricalcium aluminate, 3 CaO•Al2o3 (11%) and Tetracalcium aluminoferrite, 4 CaO•Al2o3•fe2 O3 (9%). White Portland cement is richer in alumina but free of ferric and magnesium oxides.

The setting of cement is essentially a hydration reaction to form tricalcium disilicate hydrate, 3CaO•2SiO2•3h2O. The hydrate forms a colloidal "mineral glue" which is called "Tobermite", because it is practically identical with a rare, naturally occuring mineral of that name. The reactions which occur are given below.

(2) (3CaO•SiO2) + 6 H2O -> 3CaO•2SiO2•3H2O + 3 Ca(OH)2

(2) (2CaO•SiO2) + 4H2O -> 3CaO•2SiO2•3H2O + Ca(OH)2

In the first reaction about forty percent by weight of calcium hydroxide, Ca(OH)2, or as it is sometimes called calcium hydrate, CaO•H2O, is formed. In the second reaction eighteen percent by weight of calcium hydroxide is formed. The hydration of the tricalcium aluminate is as follows:

(3) 3CaO•Al2o3 + 6H2O -> 3CaO•Al2o3•6H2 O

As soon as the cement is mixed with water, a rapid reaction starts. In a few minutes, the gauging water becomes saturated with calcium hydroxide. The di_ and tricalcium silicate is hydrated to a gel, releasing calcium hydroxide which slowly crysallizes from the solution. A microscopic examination of the hardened cement paste shows small amounts of unreacted clinker minerals and crystals of calcium hydroxide. This latter material is a basic or alkaline salt and is of considerable significance in connection with the resistance of cement to attack by aggressive reagents some of which will be discussed later.

Pages 29-31 / Section 5.2 / the entire page and a half of Section 5.2 except for the first sentence:

The primary raw material for the manufacture of portland cement is calcium carbonate or limestone and clay containing silica, aluminum and ferric oxides in the proper proportions. The mixture is calcined in a rotary kiln at a temperature of about 1450ºC to produce the required product.

The primary compounds entering into the composition of finished portland cemet are: tricalcium silicate, 3CaO•SiO2 (54%); dicalcium silicate, 2CaO•SiO2 (17%); tricalcium aluminate, 3CaO•Al2o4 (11%) and tetracalcium aluminoferrite, 4CaO•Al2o3•fe2 O3 (9%). White portland cement is richer in alumina and essentially free of ferric and magnesium oxides.

The setting of cement is essentially a hydration reaction to form calcium silicate hydrates. The hydrate forms a colloidal "mineral glue" which is called "tobermite", because it is practically identical with a rare, naturally occuring mineral of that name. The reactions which occur are given below.

3CaO•SiO2 + (X+1)H2O -> Ca2SiO4•XH2O + Ca(OH)2 + Heat(500J/g) (1)

2CaO•SiO2 + XH2O -> Ca2SiO4•XH2O + Heat(260J/g) (2)

In reaction (1) about forty percent by weight of calcium hydroxide, Ca(OH)2, or as it is sometimes called calcium hydrate, CaO•H2O, is formed. The hydration of the tricalcium aluminate is as follows:

3CaO•Al2O3 + 6H2O -> Ca3Al2(OH)12 + Heat(865J/g) (3)

As soon as the cement is mixed with water, a rapid reaction starts. In a few minutes, the gauging water becomes saturated with calcium hydroxide. The di_ and tricalcium silicate is hydrated to a gel, releasing calcium hydroxide which slowly crysallizes from the solution. reactions (1) and (3) produce rapid setting but low strength in the cement. Reaction (2) is a slower setting reaction but produces higher strength. Microscopic examination of the hardened cement paste shows small amounts of unreacted calcined minerals and crystals of calcium hydroxide. The latter is a basic or alkaline material and is of considerable significance in connection with the resistance of cement to attack by aggressive agents as is discussed below.

Page 4 / Discussion / 1st full paragraph, following two formulas, and first two sentences of following paragraph:

Adding water which has a high pH (basic) to a newly plastered pool which as we have seen has an alkaline surface can further raise the pH of the water to a sufficient level to convert the bicarbonate ion (HCO3_) present in the water to carbonate ions (CO3=). This ion then combines with soluble magnesium and calcium ions in the water to precipitate as insoluble magnesium and calcium carbonate.

HCO3_ + OH_ = CO3= + H2O

Ca++ + CO3= -> CaCO3

This is sometimes referred to as "Plaster Dust", although none of it comes from the cement itself. With water as low as 25 ppm total hardness as much as four pounds of fine chalk dust can be precipitated from the water of a 20,000 gallon pool.

Pages 31-32 / Section 5.3 / full paragraph under formula 5, formulas 6 and 7, and first two sentences of following paragraph:

Adding water which has a high pH (basic) to a newly plastered pool which has an alkaline surface can further raise the pH of the water to a sufficient level to convert the bicarbonate ion (HCO3_) present in the water to carbonate ions (CO3=). This ion then combines with soluble magnesium and calcium ions in the water to precipitate insoluble magnesium and calcium carbonates.

HCO3_ + OH_ = CO3= + H2O (6)

Ca++ + CO3= -> CaCO3 (7)

This is sometimes referred to as "plaster dust", although none of it comes from the cement itself. With water as low as 25 ppm total hardness as much as four pounds of fine chalk dust can be precipitated from the water of a 20,000 gallon pool.

Page 7 / Discussion / 1st full paragraph, second sentence:

It involves a chemical attack on the cement walls of the swimming pool resulting in the selective solvation or leaching out of the cement surface specific minerals.

Pages 32 / Section 5.3 / text following formula (8):

...can result in the chemical attack on the walls of the swimming pool resulting in the selective solvation or leaching out of mineral constituents from the marcite surface.

The Journal of the Swimming Pool and Spa Industry
letter of introduction
Criteria for Submission
JSPSI Staff and Review Board
 
Here is a list of issues, with abstracts from the articles
Vol. 1 Num. 1 -
Spring 1995
      Sample article
Volume1 Number 2 - Fall 1995
o Sample article - The Addition of Muriatic Acid - Results and Implications of Using Varied Methods of Muriatic Acid Application in Swimming Pool Water
Volume 1 Number 3 - Winter 1995
Volume 2 Number 1 - Spring 1996
Volume 2 Number 2 - Summer 1996
Volume 3 Number 1 - Spring 1998
Volume 3 Number 2 - Summer 1999
Volume 4 Number 1 - Spring 2001
Volume 4 Number 2 - Spring 2002
Volume 5 Number 1 - Spring 2004
Volume 5 Number 2 - Summer 2004 (due out August 2004)
 
The following technical research symposia were cosponsored by NSPI and various industry companies, including JSPSI. JSPSI compiled and edited the proceedings listed below, which are available from the NSPI:
1st Annual NSPI Technical Symposium (November of 1996 in Phoenix)
2nd Annual NSPI Technical Symposium (November of 1997 in Chicago)
3rd Annual NSPI Technical Symposium (November of 1998 in New Orleans)
4th Annual NSPI Technical Symposium (November of 1999 in Las Vegas)
 
Here are forms to subscribe, order back issues, and change address
Subscribe to the Journal
Order a back issue
Change your delivery address
Ask your library to subscribe
 
Links
Some interesting industry links
 
        © Copyright 2001 - onBalance - All Rights Reserved